Chicken · Slow cooker adaptation

Slow Cooker Chicken Cacciatore (Maximum Flavour)

Stephen at Not Another Cooking Show calls cacciatore a build your own adventure, and his version skips the olives in favour of a Calabrian chilli, cherry pepper and caper flavour bomb. Boneless thighs go in floured and seared, kale wilts in for heart, and the whole pot braises down until the chicken tears with a fork.

👁 524.1k source views ❤️ 13.1k source likes
Prep 35 min
🍲Slow cook 5 hr (Low) / 3 hr (High)
🍽Serves 4
No image yet

Stephen at Not Another Cooking Show cooks this as an oven braise, searing floured boneless skinless thighs in a Dutch oven, building a sauce of mushrooms, peppers, onion, garlic, kale, tomato paste, white wine and passata, then finishing it at 425F for around 1 hour 30 to 1 hour 40 minutes. It translates cleanly to the slow cooker. The searing and sauce build stay on the hob to lock in colour and Maillard flavour, then everything goes into the slow cooker for a hands off braise. He serves it alongside Kenji Lopez-Alt's crispy roast potatoes and crusty bread.

Slow cooker notes: Original is a Dutch oven braise at 425F for around 1 hour 30 to 1 hour 40 minutes. Adapted to the slow cooker by keeping the searing, mushroom and aromatic stage, and the wine deglaze on the hob (this is where the colour and depth come from), then transferring everything across. Low 5 hours or High 3 hours gives boneless skinless thighs that just fall apart, matching Stephen's stated finish point. Passata is added neat and the jar is filled once with water (per the source) to thin, since slow cookers lose very little to evaporation.

Ingredients

Main
  • boneless skinless chicken thighs, seasoned all over, dredged in flour
  • plain flour, for dredging the chicken
  • olive oil, for searing
Vegetables
  • mushrooms, stems removed, quartered (or halved if small)
  • 1bell pepper, pith removed, cut into short strips
  • 1onion, thinly sliced around the curve
  • garlic cloves, thinly sliced
  • kale, torn off the rib, washed
Herbs
  • fresh thyme, tied with the rosemary in a bundle
  • fresh rosemary, tied with the thyme in a bundle
  • 1bay leaf, whole
Flavour bomb
  • 1 tbspchopped Calabrian chilli peppers
  • 0.5 jarcherry peppers in oil, with some of the packing juices
  • 1.5 tbspcapers
Sauce
  • 2 tbsptomato paste
  • dry white wine, for the deglaze
  • 1 jartomato passata
  • 1 jarwater, used to rinse the passata jar
  • dried oregano, pinch
To finish
  • Parmesan cheese, grated (add late)
  • fresh parsley, chopped (add late)
To serve
  • crusty bread (add late)

Method

  1. Stem and quarter the mushrooms, keeping smaller ones whole or halved. Cut the top off the bell pepper, shave off the white pith and slice into short strips. Trim, peel and thinly slice the onion. Thinly slice the garlic. Tie the thyme and rosemary into a small bundle with kitchen string.

    ~10 min
  2. Build the flavour bomb in a small bowl: stir together the chopped Calabrian chilli, half a jar of cherry peppers with some of their oil and juices, and the capers.

    ~2 min
  3. Tear the kale off its ribs into bite sized pieces and soak in cold water to wash. Drain when ready to use.

    ~3 min
  4. Season the chicken thighs on all sides with salt and pepper, then dredge in flour. A mesh strainer with a few tablespoons of flour in it makes light work of dusting.

    ~5 min
  5. Heat a large frying pan or casserole on medium high. Add a glug of olive oil and sear the thighs a few at a time, a few minutes per side, until golden brown. Don't crowd the pan and don't push the heat so high that the flour burns. Transfer each batch to a bowl.

    ~12 min
  6. Tip the mushrooms into the hot pan with a pinch of salt. They will drink up the oil, so add a little more if needed. Cook hot and fast until they smell roasty, a few minutes.

    ~5 min
  7. Add the sliced garlic with a touch more oil if dry. Once aromatic, add the onion and bell pepper, season with salt and cook until they begin to soften.

    ~6 min
  8. Stir in the flavour bomb mixture. After half a minute, add the kale a handful at a time with a pinch of salt and let it wilt down.

    ~3 min
  9. Stir in the tomato paste and cook for a couple of minutes until you see caramelisation building on the bottom of the pan. Deglaze with the white wine, scraping up the fond with a flat spoon.

    ~4 min
  10. Tip the pan contents into the slow cooker. Add the herb bundle, the bay leaf, the passata, then refill the empty passata jar with water and add that too. Season with salt and stir.

    ~3 min
  11. Nestle the seared chicken thighs into the sauce along with any resting juices, and add a pinch of dried oregano.

    ~2 min
  12. Cover and slow cook on Low for 5 hours, or on High for 3 hours, until the chicken is just barely holding together and shreds with a fork.

    ~300 min
  13. Lift out and discard the herb bundle and bay leaf. Taste the sauce and adjust salt. Serve in a bowl with plenty of the sauce, scatter over Parmesan and parsley, and put crusty bread alongside.

    ~5 min

Frequently asked

Do I need to sear the chicken first?
Yes. Slow cookers steam, they don't brown, so the floured crust on the thighs and the fond left in the pan are where most of the depth of flavour comes from. Stephen is clear on this in the source.
What if I can't find Calabrian chilli or cherry peppers?
They are the heart of Stephen's version, but at a push you can use any jarred mild chilli in oil plus a small splash of red wine vinegar for the bright acidity. The result won't be quite the same, but it will still be a respectable cacciatore.
Can I use bone in thighs?
Yes. Sear them the same way and add 1 to 2 hours on Low (or 30 to 60 minutes on High). The boneless choice in the source is for ease of eating, not flavour.
Can I leave out the kale?
Yes. Stephen notes kale isn't traditional in cacciatore, he adds it for heartiness and some greens. Leave it out for a more classic version, or swap in cavolo nero or chard.
What do I serve it with?
Crusty bread to mop up the sauce, finished with Parmesan and parsley. Stephen serves it with Kenji Lopez-Alt's crispy roast potatoes on the side, which are worth the extra effort if you have the oven free.
Extraction notes (transparency): Several quantities not stated in transcript and left null: boneless skinless chicken thighs (count and weight), mushrooms, bell pepper (1 implied, the bell pepper), onion (1 implied, the onion), garlic (a few cloves), kale, flour for dredging, olive oil for searing, white wine for deglaze, salt, pepper, dried oregano (pinch), Parmesan and parsley to finish. Slow cooker timing inferred from boneless skinless thighs in liquid; original cook is oven braised, not slow cooked. Default servings (4) inferred, not stated. Side of Kenji Lopez-Alt's potatoes documented as a serving suggestion but the recipe is the cacciatore itself.